How to Make Pie in Grow a Garden
What Is Pie in Grow a Garden?
Pie is one of the ten dishes in the 2025 Cooking Event. It always starts with a pumpkin-based batter and is cooked in the lobby Cooking Pot. The only reason to bake it is to feed Chris P. Pig: the rarer the pie, the better the chest he spits out. A Prismatic Pie also counts toward the hidden "Glitter-Gourmet" badge.
All Grow a Garden Pie Cooking Recipes
Pie
Base Cook Time:
7 min 52 s
Pot Water Color:
Green
Cooking Recipe Options:
Common
Option 1:
x1 Sugar Apple, x1 Pumpkin, x1 Giant Pinecone, x1 Apple, x1 Corn, x1 Pumpkin
Legendary
Option 1:
x1 Pumpkin, x1 Moon Melon
Option 2:
x1 Pumpkin, x1 Giant Pinecone, x1 Corn, x1 Apple
Option 3:
x1 Pumpkin, x1 Pineapple
Mythical
Option 1:
x1 Apple, x1 Pumpkin
Option 2:
x1 Pumpkin, x1 Beanstalk
Option 3:
x1 Pumpkin, x1 Ember Lily
Divine
Option 1:
x1 Coconut, x1 Beanstalk
Option 2:
x1 Sugarglaze, x1 Beanstalk
Option 3:
x1 Pepper, x1 Coconut, x2 Elder Strawberry, x1 Celestiberry
Option 4:
x3 Sugar Apple, x1 Pumpkin
Prismatic
Option 1:
x4 Bone Blossom, x1 Pumpkin
Option 2:
x2 Bone Blossom, x1 Coconut
Option 3:
x4 Bone Blossom, x1 Coconut
Option 4:
x3 Bone Blossom, x1 Coconut, x1 Sugar Apple
How to Cook Pie in Grow a Garden
Gather crops listed above—Bone Blossoms come from Graveyard plots; Coconuts from Tropical Trees.
Walk to the Cooking Pot, press E on each crop until all five slots glow green.
Hit COOK; the wooden sign shows the timer. Large crops ⇧ time but give more loot points.
When the bell rings, press E again to collect your pie. The border colour shows its rarity.
Optional: stockpile pies until the pig's speech bubble asks for one.
Tip: Using Cleaning Spray before adding Bone Blossoms wipes old mutations and keeps the timer low.
Pie Cooking-Event Rewards
| Pie Rarity | Guaranteed Drop | Bonus Roll Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Normal / Uncommon | Food Crate, 2k – 5k Sheckles | Basic Seeds |
| Legendary | Advanced Sprinkler, Mutation Spray Wet | Gourmet Seed Pack |
| Mythical | Medium Toy, HoneyGlazed Spray | Gourmet Egg |
| Divine | Pretzel Cart décor, Medium Treat | Level-Up Lollipop |
| Prismatic | Mythical+ Chest, Chef Badge +1 | Pancake Stack décor, Star Caller token |
Achievement: Feeding ten Prismatic pies unlocks the Glitter-Gourmet title and +5% crop-sale bonus for good.